![]() When Carr had comparable help, he had similar stats. He had a far superior supporting cast so he's obviously more productive. Wentz was more productive most recently so he's the better player now This is essentially the debate we're having: Idk I got guys quoting me Foles stats from 2013 so 6 years? But either way like I've said you don't get to pick and choose what sample size is relevant and ignore context because it fits your argument. That doesn't exactly mean he got significantly better But his production is significantly better. Did he actually get that much better from 2016 or did everything around him get better? He still has the exact same issues that scouts complained about before the draft. The conclusion I'm drawing is that we've seen how productive they can be in optimal situations. The conclusion you're drawing is that the earlier seasons were outliers and irrelevant. At the same time there's little difference between Dak's 2017, Carr's 2017 and Wentz's 2016 in how weak their help was. There's really no difference between the supporting cast strengths of Wentz's 2017, Carr's 2016 and Daks 2016. Production is cast dependent especially for young QBs You wanna toss out earlier seasons instead of just applying context so that you can imply that more recent production indicates more recent development. No I simply believe all the sample size matters not just the one that makes my argument stronger. ![]() ![]() But it does appear like he is getting worse since the 2016 season. You may be right that his int rate is his 2nd best of his career at 1.8 but his career average is 1.9.Īs for Y/A, it's easy to say that it's the best of his career. He had a near 5-1 TD to Int ratio on 2016. I place value on scoring and taking care of the ball. You're the one that said something erroneous. I'm not arguing his team composition or even saying he is bad. He even threw for more yards per game but didnt play in week 17, so naturally, had fewer total yards. He was better in every stat in 2016 except completion percentage. You said this was the best year of his career which isnt close to right. You seem to be putting a lot of value on completion percentage. /r/usfl - United States Football League./r/footballcards - Football Card Collecting./r/footballstrategy - Football Strategy. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |